Skip to main content

A Salt Bae Lawsuit Provides a Valuable Reminder About Tipping

 

Fort Lauderdale Personal Chef

Print Friendly and PDF
Employees argued that a service charge at the Nurs-Et Miami should not have covered their wages. A court disagreed.


We have removed part of the beginning of the article. There is a link to full article below.

... But if Salt Bae has taught us three things, this might actually be the most important one: a service charge is not necessarily a tip. And if you're paying a service charge, that fee can be used as part of an employee's wages and does not entirely have to be given to staff on top of their normal pay.

This lesson comes courtesy of the United States Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit which on Friday upheld the decision of a Miami federal judge who ruled that an 18% "service charge" added to bills at the Nurs-Et Steakhouse in Miami – which is owned by Nusret Gokce, a.k.a. Salt Bae – was not a tip because it was not at the sole discretion of the customer. (For the record, yes, the phrase "Salt Bae" does appear in the ruling, once.)

As the ruling states, "If the mandatory service charges are tips, federal law would generally prohibit restaurants from using the fees to pay minimum and overtime wages to employees. But if the charges are not tips, establishments may apply them toward employee wages." 

Two dozen Nurs-Et employees sued the establishment, arguing that this service charge shouldn't have been used to cover their normal wages, but ultimately, the court ruled in favor of the restaurant. It's a decision that Reuters points out is in line with a 2020 4th Circuit decision that determined that an automatic 20% gratuity for large parties is also not officially a tip.

Interestingly, the language used by Nurs-Et does sound similar to what a customer might believe a "tip" to be. "For your convenience an 18% service charge will be added to your final bill and will be distributed to the entire team," the menu is quoted as reading in the ruling.

However, in its decision, the court cites a precedent which stated that "the essential element of a tip is its voluntary nature." And the court later adds, "The FLSA [Fair Labor Standards Act] defines neither 'tip' nor 'service charge.' But as noted in Department of Labor  ("DOL") regulations, the critical feature of a 'tip' is that '[w]hether a tip is to be given, and its amount, are matters determined solely by the customer.'"

The court also cites another DOL regulation providing an example of what is not a tip: "A compulsory charge for service, such as 15% of the amount of the bill, imposed on a customer by an employer's establishment, is not a tip." The court then continues,  "We simply cannot distinguish between Nusret's service charge and this example."

Worth noting is that, during the period covering the Nurs-Et employees' complaint – November 1, 2017 through January 1, 2019 – staff was found to have made amounts ranging from $23.68 to $51.58 per hour. So everyone involved was making well over minimum wage.

Still, a larger moral exists beyond a bill at Nurs-Et: Be mindful of any additional charges or fees that are not entirely at your discretion. And if you're unsure how a service charge is being used, it might behoove you to clarify it with your server.

Full article on FOOD&WINE.

personal chefs and event catering
Miami + Miami Beach + Fort Lauderdale + Palm Beach
info@yadachef.com | 954-367-YADA (9232)

Popular posts from this blog

Italian Cream Pie Recipe

This cream pie, often served at Easter and Christmas is rich and, oh, so, good. The recipe has been handed down from my Nonna's family who came to the USA in the late 1800's The basic recipe is for a vanilla cream pie, but you can also sometimes made a half vanilla/half chocolate cream pie by melting a couple of chocolate squares into half of the Italian cream. Then, pour the chocolate and vanilla creams into the crust at the same time (easier with help) so that  they bump up against each other, but don’t mix. You can also pour the cream in two layers. 1 Quart/1 liter Milk 1 Cup/200g Sugar 3 Tablespoons/22.5g Cornstarch 8 Egg Yolks 1 Orange Peel (One Large Orange) Orange Flavouring ( we use the juice of 1/2 an orange and reduce until a thick syrup) Important: At no time should this mixture come to a boil. If it does, throw out and start over. Always stir slowly counter clockwise. From start to finish, the mixture must be stirred at all times. Combine milk, sugar, egg yolks,...

Pasta with Smoked White Fish, Tomatoes and Garlic Recipe

This recipe was originally written for smoked white fish. Our clients wanted fresh salmon so we roasted some salmon fillets.  You get the recipe 2 ways Serves 4-5 1pound/450g linguine OR penne pasta 6 tablespoons/90ml olive oil 3 large shallots, finely chopped (about 3/4 cup/180ml ) 1 1/2 tablespoons/22ml finely chopped garlic 1 1/2 pounds/675g cherry tomatoes, halved (about 24 tomatoes) large handful fresh parsley, finely chopped r 3/4 teaspoon/4ml dried crushed red pepper (Optional) *18 ounces/510g smoked whitefish (chunks),* skinned, boned, coarsely flaked (original) or *18 ounces/510g fresh salmon fillets skinned olive oil to drizzle salt and pepper Preheat oven to 400F/200C/Gas 6  On a lined baking sheet place the salmon fillets.  Drizzle with olive oil and season both sides with salt and pepper.  Place in preheated oven and bake for 10-15 minutes, making sure you can flake the fish, but it is still slightly undercook...

Anchovy Essence Recipe

  Anchovy essence  is a handy cupboard staple that will anonymously enhance just about anything savory that you choose to cook. Your dish will have no hint of fish; it will, however, taste more like itself. This recipe almost belongs to Maxine de la Falaise, who proves that they do not make names like once they did. She writes in  Seven Centuries of English Cooking   (London 1973) that “[t]here are many, many recipes for this English essence  par excellence.  It is said to have been introduced by the Romans, whose  liquamen , made from rotting fish, was described by Apicius.” Her recipe, as she notes, derives from several nineteenth century formulae; ours in turn derives from hers. -a 3.35 oz/103 ml jar of anchovies packed in olive oil -1 Tablespoon/15 ml malt vinegar -1 Tablespoon/15ml water -1 teaspoon/4 ml lemon zest -¼ teaspoon/1 ml cayenne Drain the anchovies and mash them to a rough pulp; a fork or teaspoon is the only tool you need. Put the pulp...

Homemade Turkey Ham Recipe

Making your own cured turkey “ham”, is not only healthier, but in our opinion much tastier.  It will be much lower in sodium and be preservative free.  You are going to use turkey in 3 different forms. Cubed, minced and pureed.  This will give it a more “ham” like texture. Start with 2 pounds 10.5 ounces of skin off deboned turkey thigh meat Cubed Turkey 14 ounces/400 grams turkey meat, cut into cubes  1 teaspoon/4 grams salt 1/4  teaspoon/1 grams curing salt Minced/Ground Turkey (if you use pre minced make sure it’s thigh meat) 14 ounces/400 grams turkey meat 1 teaspoon/4 grams salt 1/2 teaspoon/2 grams curing salt  2 Tablespoons plus 2 teaspoons/40mls water For The Puree 10.5 ounces/300 grams turkey meat 4 teaspoons/20mls water 1/2 teaspoon/2mls garlic powder   1 teaspoon/4 grams salt 1/2 teaspoon/2 grams curing salt  1 large egg white 2 teaspoons/10ml liquid smoke 1/2 tablespoon/2 grams smoked paprika  Trim the turkey if not trimmed alread...

Braised Lettuce (Laitues Braises): A Take On Julia Child’s Recipe

You can use almost any lettuce, such as chicory, or frisee, or Boston Bib if you are busing large heads, cut them in half. We made these pescartarian because of the shrimp stock, but vegan is easy with vegetable stock, or if serving with beef, a  beef stock and bacon. Braised lettuce is a delicious garnish for poultry, white meats such as veal or pork, or steamed white fish. It can be the main accompanied by a warm sweet potato salad. Serves 4 4 heads Romaine lettuce hearts  4 thick slices of bacon (if making not vegetarian or vegan), cut into lardon strips 1 small onion , diced 2 carrots, diced 1 tablespoon/15g plus 1/2 tablespoon/7 butter divided  1 teaspoon/5ml olive oil 1/2 cup/125ml shrimp or seafood stock (see notes above) 1/2 cup/125ml cup white wine or dry white vermouth bouquet garni: 1 parsley branch, 1 branch of thyme,1  bay leaf tied to a cheesecloth ½ tablespoon butter 1 tablespoon parsley Trim stems of lettuce and ...

Do you Remember Herman? Sourdough Starter and Recipe

In the late 1970s and early 1980s, Amish friendship bread, as well as an interchangeable starter referred to as Herman (the name varies), became a popular exchange among friends who shared the starter as well as recipes. Herman Starter Preparation time: 10 minutes Standing time: 5 days Yield: 4 cups 1 cup sugar 1/3 cup warm water 2 packages (2 1/4 teaspoons each) active dry yeast 2 cups each: milk, flour 1. Sprinkle 1 tablespoon of the sugar over the warm water. Sprinkle yeast over mixture; set aside until doubled in volume, about 10 minutes. 2. Combine milk, flour, remaining sugar and yeast mixture in a plastic or glass container. (Do not use metal.) Stir with a wooden spoon; cover loosely. Set aside at room temperature, at least 8 hours. 3. Stir mixture once a day for three days. On the fourth day, measure out 1 cup of Herman for baking; measure 1 additional cup to give to a friend as a gift. To replenish starter: Add 1 cup flour, 1 cup milk and 1...

Eat Your Vegetables - They Are Good For You

There's no question that eating three to five servings of fruits and vegetables daily will improve your health. But more and more experts are saying healthy eat ing is not only about how many servings you eat. It's about the variety you pick, too. Eat a diet of solely white foods, and you'll miss key nutrients your body needs—even if your palette includes cauliflower, onions, and mushrooms. Adding a multivitamin doesn't cut it either. "People will say, 'I'm taking a multivitamin, so I don't really need to eat these,' " says Karin Hosenfeld, RD, LD, a dietitian in private practice in Dallas, but she says scientists don't know whether whole foods may offer undiscovered benefits that vitamins don't. "We do know for sure that if you don't eat your fruits and vegetables, you're not getting your fiber, and that's [helping keep] your blood sugar down." Every one of your meals doesn't have to be multicolored...

Wine Jelly/Jello Recipe

Yes that’s right!  Wine! These go great with a sharp cheese, such as Feta and Blue.  You can swap the wine and pair it with whatever cheese you normally would.  Serves 6 2 ¼ cups/570ml Manischewitz Concord Grape Red Wine ¼ ounce/7g packet of powdered gelatin Pour wine in a medium saucepan.  Sprinkle the gelatin over and stir in.  Place it on a medium low burner and stir constantly for 1-2 minutes.  Ladle equal amounts into 4 custard cups.  Place in the fridge to set.  personal chefs and event catering Miami + Miami Beach + Fort Lauderdale + Palm Beach info@yadachef.com | 954-367-YADA (9232) www.yadachef.com

Kids Cooking Class - Palm Beach, Fort Lauderdale, Miami

YaDa Chef's cooking school JUST for kids! Teaching children of all ages that cooking can be creative, full of discovery, and a lot of fun!  YaDa Chef provides hands-on cooking classes allowing kid's imaginations to run wild and free while discovering new science, math, reading, health and social skills. YaDa Chef offers a unique culinary experience offering cooking classes to children in an environment that encourages discover and creativity.  Each class is a new experience.  Themes chosen, either our one of YaDa Chef's chefs, by the child or parent assist in sharpening skills and taking the mystery out of the kitchen.  Removing the fear of the unknown while incorporating subject matter which ties into each theme. Our highly qualified chefs, in coordination of nutritional experts carry out a mission to provide an interactive learning experience giving children the opportunity to develop a life-long love of the culinary arts. Each class is designed to fa...

2024 Passover Menus For Delivery

YaDa Chef’s 2024 Passover Menu    The following menus are for delivery. Restrictions, delivery fee (if applicable) and availability apply. We also provide in-house personal chef services. Call +1 954-367-9232 or + 1 561-285-7466 or email  info@yadachef.com  for more information.  Ashkenazi – INFLUENCED  Menu 1 - Serves 8-10   $433 Traditional Chopped Chicken liver with Matzo points Cabbage and Carrot Coleslaw Pickled Beet Salad Gefilte Fish Loaf with Fresh Horseradish Vegetable or Chicken soup with Matzo Balls Traditional Roast Chicken with 40 Cloves of Garlic Traditional or Sweet Potato Kugel Roasted Mixed Vegetable or Carrot Kugel Menu 2 - Serves 8-10   $487 Traditional Chopped Chicken liver with Matzo points Cabbage and Carrot Coleslaw Pickled Beet Salad Gefilte Fish Loaf with Fresh Horseradish Vegetable or Chicken soup with Matzo Balls Traditional Beef Brisket with dried cranberry and Gravy Traditional or Sweet Potato Kugel Roasted Mixed Veget...